Gunners

Reviews

• Al M.

  star star star star star_border 9 October 2026

  "Gunners:  Eat, Drink, Sleep"...a motto I can live with, especially when the food and service are this good.
  
  In this small town of 12,000 in north central PA, Gunners was named for the guns sold to local hunters by the owners of Ammo and Arms when those owners branched out into the restaurant business in 2004.
  
  New owners took over in 2013 and have aimed to transform the local sports bar into an establishment with much wider appeal. Today, Gunners offers both the burger & a beer (from Straubs Brewery just down the street) all the way up to fine dining for both locals and travelers alike.
  
  Here on business, several locals recommended that we dine at Gunners over a more upscale Italian alternative...good call!
  
  With the wise guidance of our cheerful server Tabitha, our group of three ordered a Delmonico Steak, a Honey Glazed Salmon and a Tuna Catch. Each entree far surpassed our expectations in quality and taste. Straub Brewery's various selections on draft perfectly complimented our dinner choices.
  
  Gunners did the trick...Great food and a very enjoyable overall experience.

• Curtis B.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 9 October 2026

  I gave this place one star because they have a decent beer selection. Other than that if your going to eat there you better bring a snack. I went there tonight with my wife and two children it took over 50 minutes to get our appetizers and my wife's salad. There were people all around us that received their meals before our appetizers and they showed up 15 minutes after us! Then the main meal came out after an hour and a half, food was ok but was too upset to enjoy it. When I wanted to give the server some constructive criticism she didn't want to hear it and sent another server over to listen to me because she said she was sick!!! Real nice!!! Just paid my bill and left and will never be back. Thanks gunners .

• Amy D.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 2 October 2026

  Terrible service.
  and the fastest part of the whole night was getting our prime rib before even being done with the salad.
  worst prime rib I have ever had... (tough as cube steak) almost choked on it and had no flavor had to put salt on it to eat it.
  very overpriced

• Russ S.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 22 September 2026

  I sorta feel stupid because I didn't read the reviews here before I went.But my sister wanted to go.So,what's you do. We all had their prime rib special. It was the worst prime rib I have ever had. The meat was so tough the we struggle to chew it. Service was bad. The bar maid was good . Once I found her. The bartender blew me off when I first ordered only because he was making a cocktail for another patron which obviously he was struggling to make. It's sad that out of four prime rib orders all cooked from rare to medium well not one was edible. Sad.
  I am only given it a 1 star because you can't rate it any lower.

• Harvey I.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 20 September 2026

  Excellent food severely marred by poor management.  Four of us went for dinner Saturday night September 29.  We were seated at 730pm.  Excellent menu.  Even better craft beer list!  We ordered drinks, one order of fried calamari,  and four entrees.  Our doe eyed waitress Natalie was stressed with a 20 top in the main room and with the four of us in the back room.  Needless to say the wait for her was often terrible.  We didn't leave until 1030pm...three hours later.  First, they were out of the beer we ordered from the craft menu.  But we had to wait for her to come back and tell us.  Next...they were out of three of the entrees we ordered.  You're correct...we had to wait for her to come back to tell us.  In fact...one of the entrees was the Saturday night special....and it was still listed on the board at the restaurant entrance when we left!  What a horrible dining experience for our first time in St Mary's.  Pay attention to YELP and go somewhere else!